The WWE Universe was rocked this week by news that Sonya Deville—one of the most groundbreaking and outspoken superstars in recent memory—has been informed that WWE will not renew her contract. For fans who’ve followed her journey from NXT underdog to SmackDown authority figure, this announcement feels like a sudden twist in a storyline no one saw coming. But what does this mean for Deville, her legacy, and WWE’s future? Let’s unpack the drama, the history, and the possibilities ahead.
From Soccer Fields to Squared Circles
Before she became a WWE standout, Sonya Deville (real name Daria Berenato) was a professional MMA fighter and even appeared on Tough Enough in 2015. Unlike many wrestlers who grow up dreaming of WWE, Deville’s path was unconventional. She traded octagons for turnbuckles, bringing a gritty, authentic fighting style to the ring.
Breaking Barriers in WWE
Deville made history as WWE’s first openly gay female superstar, using her platform to advocate for LGBTQ+ representation. Her authenticity resonated with fans, and she became a role model for inclusivity in an industry often criticized for lagging behind on social issues.
The Rise and Reinvention of Sonya Deville :
Early Days in NXT and Absolution
Debuting in NXT in 2017, Deville quickly joined Paige’s faction, Absolution, alongside Mandy Rose. The trio terrorized the women’s division, but it was Deville’s intensity and MMA-inspired moves that set her apart.
Feuds That Defined Her Career
- Vs. Mandy Rose: Their real-life friendship turned into an on-screen rivalry, culminating in a hair vs. hair match at SummerSlam 2020.
- Authority Figure Arc: After injury setbacks, Deville transitioned into a power-hungry official on SmackDown, showcasing her mic skills and villainous charisma.
Why WWE Isn’t Renewing Her Contract :
Creative Differences or Budget Cuts?
Rumors suggest WWE’s recent cost-cutting measures played a role, but insiders also hint at Deville’s frustration with creative direction. Did the company fail to capitalize on her potential?
Injury Woes and Screen Time
A torn ACL in 2023 sidelined Deville for nearly a year. While she thrived in non-wrestling roles, her absence from the ring may have affected her bargaining power.
The “Triple H Effect”
Since Triple H took over creative, some talents have been repackaged or released as part of his vision. Could Deville’s exit reflect this shift?
Fan Reactions: Outrage, Heartbreak, and Support :
Social Media Erupts
Twitter and Reddit exploded with #ThankYouSonya trends, while critics blasted WWE for letting go of a trailblazer. One fan tweeted, “First Naomi, now Sonya? Who’s left to represent marginalized voices?”
Peers Weigh In
Fellow wrestlers like Bayley and Carmella praised Deville’s work ethic. Even Mandy Rose, now in the indie circuit, posted a heartfelt tribute: “Changed the game forever.”
Sonya’s Legacy: More Than Just a Wrestler :
LGBTQ+ Advocacy
Deville’s visibility helped normalize queer representation in WWE. She often spoke about her relationship with her girlfriend Toni Cassano, blending personal pride with professional storytelling.
Redefining Women’s Roles
Whether as a fighter or a corporate heel, Deville proved women could excel beyond “pretty face” tropes. Her authoritative character was a masterclass in mic work and nuance.
What’s Next for Sonya Deville?
AEW: The Obvious Contender
All Elite Wrestling has scooped up released WWE talent before (see: Cody Rhodes, Jade Cargill). With AEW’s focus on in-ring diversity, Deville’s MMA background could shine.
Hollywood or MMA Return?
Deville has acting credits (Southpaw Regional Wrestling) and could pivot to action films. Or, might she return to MMA with promotions like Bellator?
Independent Circuit Opportunities
Smaller promotions like Impact Wrestling or STARDOM Japan would benefit from her star power—and she’d have more creative freedom.
How This Affects WWE’s Women’s Division:
A Void in Representation
With Deville gone, WWE loses one of its few openly LGBTQ+ stars. Will this push them to elevate others, like Piper Niven or Tegan Nox?
Creative Opportunities for Remaining Talent
Could this open doors for rising NXT stars like Cora Jade or Roxanne Perez to fill Deville’s spot as a dominant heel?
Lessons from Sonya’s Career :
Authenticity Wins
Deville never hid who she was, and fans respected her for it. In an era of scripted promos, her realness stood out.
Adapt or Get Left Behind
From in-ring bruiser to scheming executive, Deville evolved constantly. Her flexibility kept her relevant despite injuries and booking changes.
The Business Side of WWE Contracts:
How Contracts Work in WWE
Unlike team sports, WWE contracts are talent agreements with strict terms. Releases often hinge on budget, creative plans, or backstage politics.
The “90-Day Non-Compete” Clause
Even if Deville’s contract isn’t renewed, she’ll likely wait 90 days before joining rivals like AEW—unless WWE waives the clause.
Could Sonya Return to WWE Someday?
The “Boomerang” Effect
Wrestlers like Drew McIntyre and Jaxson Ryker left and returned stronger. If Deville thrives elsewhere, WWE might re-sign her at a higher value.
Hall of Fame Potential?
While premature, her impact on LGBTQ+ representation makes her a future HOF contender—especially if she continues advocacy post-WWE.
Fan Theories and Wild Speculations:
Is This a Work?
Conspiracy theorists wonder if this is a storyline to write her off TV. Unlikely, but WWE has pulled swerves before.
Surprise Royal Rumble Entry?
Imagine Deville returning in 2024’s Rumble to confront her replacements. A long shot, but wrestling loves surprises.
Sonya’s Final WWE Moments: A Retrospective :
Last Match and Promo
Her final in-ring bout was a tag team match on SmackDown in July 2023. Her last promo? A chilling warning to Adam Pearce: “You’ll regret crossing me.”
Unfinished Storylines
A simmering feud with Shotzi and a hinted alliance with Scarlett were left hanging. What could’ve been?
The Bigger Picture: WWE’s Release Strategy :
Pattern or Anomaly?
WWE has released over 100 talents since 2020. Is Deville’s exit part of a trend, or a one-off due to her unique circumstances?
Impact on Talent Morale
Backstage, releases can create anxiety. How will Deville’s departure affect locker room dynamics?
How Fans Can Support Sonya Moving Forward :
Follow Her Next Chapter
Track her social media for updates on indie bookings, advocacy work, or new ventures.
Buy Merchandise
Snag her “Pride Fighter” shirts or custom gear to show love—and help her financially post-WWE.
Conclusion:
The End of an Era, the Start of a New Journey
Sonya Deville’s WWE exit marks the close of a groundbreaking chapter, but it’s far from the end of her story. Whether she dominates in AEW, returns to MMA, or becomes a full-time advocate, her legacy as a pioneer is cemented. For WWE, losing her is a wake-up call to value diverse voices. For fans? We’ll miss her presence but can’t wait to see what’s next. After all, in wrestling—and life—the best stories are about reinvention.
FAQs:
Why didn’t WWE renew Sonya Deville’s contract?
While not officially confirmed, factors likely include budget cuts, creative differences, and her recent injury history.
Could Sonya Deville join AEW?
It’s possible! AEW has signed many ex-WWE stars, and her skill set aligns with their in-ring style.
What was Sonya Deville’s biggest WWE moment?
Her 2020 “Loser Leaves WWE” match against Mandy Rose at SummerSlam is a fan favorite.
Will Sonya Deville return to WWE someday?
Never say never—wrestling is full of surprises. If the timing and deal are right, a comeback could happen.
How can I keep up with Sonya Deville post-WWE?
Follow her on Instagram (@sonyadevillewwe) and Twitter (@SonyaDevilleWWE) for updates on her next moves.